Elul Recall
  Rabbi Miller's Emails to College Students

  Return to Table of Contents
 
Chanukah
   
 

24 Kislev 5770

December 11th , 2009

 

 

To My Dear Students,

 

An ancient debate between Rabbis Hillel and Shammai reveals the essence of Judaism.

Shammai instructed his followers to light eight lights on the first night of Chanukah, seven lights on the second night, six lights on the third night, and so on until they would light one light on the eighth night of Chanukayh.

Hillel instructed his followers to light one light on the first night of Chanukah, two lights on the second night, three lights on the third night, and so on until they would light eight lights on the eighth night of Chanukah.

Shammai's reasoning was realistic: after the Maccabees lit the light, there was less and less oil on each succeeding day.

Hillel's reasoning was optimistic: every succeeding day, the Maccabees were even more inspired by the miracle of the light that lasted beyond expectations.

As we know, Jewish practice follows Rabbi Hillel.

We want our homes, our lives, our relationships, to be ever brighter, not less bright, as the days pass.  Ours is a religion of hope that tomorrow can be brighter than today.  The best is yet to be, our dreams will be realized, our yearnings will be fulfilled.

That is why you will never find a "Shammai House" on a college campus.   It is Hillel's instruction that triumphs.  The message of Chanukah is as he taught: ever more light, for us and for our world!

Shabbat Shalom v'Chag Sameach!

Your Rabbi