Elul Recall
  Rabbi Miller's Emails to College Students

  Return to Table of Contents
 
Ten Commandments
   
 

21 Shevat 5770

February 5th, 2010

 

 

To My Dear Students,

A Rabbi was invited to Shabbat dinner at the home of a congregant.  In the course of conversation, the congregant asked the Rabbi what he was going to preach that evening.  The Rabbi replied that he was considering speaking about Shabbat observance.

"You can't do that, Rabbi," retorted the congregant.  "Most of our members do not observe Shabbat and you should not offend them."

"Well," said the Rabbi, "perhaps I will speak about the importance of respecting parents, not committing adultery, and the importance of the family in our tradition."

"But Rabbi," said the congregant, "don't you know that many of our congregants' family life leaves much to be desired?"

"All right," said the Rabbi, "I will preach about morality."

"You can't do that Rabbi.  Some of our members are known to have their ethical weaknesses and they will think you are singling them out."

"I see your point," said the Rabbi.  "Perhaps I should speak about social justice."

"Impossible Rabbi, we don't want to make waves over the controversial issues.  You don't want to get involved in politics."

"Perhaps," said the Rabbi, "you would be kind enough to suggest a topic for my sermon?"

"That's simple, Rabbi.  Why don't you just talk about the Ten Commandments?"

This story is directed at anyone who would strip Judaism of its positive and specific demands.  The dark humor lies in the fact that there is no such thing as a Judaism that is divorced from actual practice.  There is no word in classical Hebrew for "religion," as though religion was a separate category.  Torah is to govern everything we do.  The Ten Commandments, which we read in this week's Portion, are to guide us in the living room, the board room, the class room, the market place, while we work and while we play, when we lie down and when we rise up, when we sit in our home and when we walk by the way.

Judaism is a way of life.


Shabbat Shalom,

Your Rabbi