Elul Recall
  Rabbi Miller's Emails to College Students

  Return to Table of Contents
 
Why People Do What They Do
   
 

19 Cheshvan 5770

November 6th , 2009

 

 

To My Dear Students,

 

Judging why people do what they do is a difficult task.  Often there is a different motivation than what appears on the surface.

Rabbi Yaakov Asher Sinclair writes that there are people who look like they are giving when, in fact, they are really taking.  And there are people who look like they are taking when, in truth, they are really giving.

When people contribute tzedaka, for example, they may do so out of less than noble motives:  for recognition, for a tax deduction, or to out-do someone else and appear superior in status.

Here is a story of a person who looked like he was taking but who, in reality, was giving.

A Jewish man found himself in a largely non-Jewish town on Friday afternoon.   His business had delayed him beyond his expectations and there was now no way he could get home for Shabbat.  He had heard that there was just one Jewish family in town where he could spend Shabbat, and as the sun was starting to set he made his way there.

The owner of the house opened the door to him and showed him into the living room.  "May I stay here for Shabbat?"  asked the stranded visitor.  "If you like," replied the host.  "The price is $200."  "200!" exclaimed the stranger.  "That is more than a first-class hotel!"  "Suit yourself," replied the host.  Realizing that he had no option, the salesman reluctantly agreed.  In the short time left before Shabbat, the host showed the salesman his room, the kitchen, and the other facilities for his Shabbat stay.

As soon as the host left the room, the salesman sat down and thought to himself.  "Well, if this is going to cost me $200, I am going to get my money's worth."  During the entire Shabbat he availed himself tirelessly and completely of the house's considerable facilties.  He helped himself to the delicious food in the refrigerator.  He had a long luxurious bath before and after Shabbat.  He really made himself "at home."

When he was about to leave, he put two $100 bills down on the table in front of his host.  "What is this?" inquired the host.  "That is the money I owe you," replied the stranger.  "You don't owe me anything.  Do you really think I would take money from a fellow Jew for the mitzvah of hospitality?"  "But you told me that Shabbat here costs $200."  "I only told you that to be sure that you would make yourself at home."

We are all strangers in this world.  It is good to make each other feel "at home" through our generosity of spirit and substance!

Shabbat Shalom,

 

Your Rabbi